me; I think cestlamort's "presence" description just about hits the nail on the head--I kept mentally reaching for a nonexistent "MORE" knob, and I think I really missed the random wobble of the Echolette's capstan wheel which the El Cap's "wow and flutter" control was never really able to replicate in any meaningful way. The Stymon's notable deficiency in magikal Klemt tube preamp compression was certainly a contributing factor to its booting too.”
“Who knows, maybe the 'feel' of Strymon tape echo sims has come a long way in the years since the El Cap was released?
TLDR; yes, now you can have a present delay if you don’t go overboard dialing up all the settings to 10.
The pre amp compression is one thing this pedal has over the El Capistan. That and the ability to select multiple heads instead of the preset head selection are the two things I always wished the El Capistan had. I don’t know if it will sound like the Klemt, but no need to buy an EP Booster pedal anymore.
I missed a few things checking it out on my phone, but found I missed a few details besides there being 8 presets. The reverse playback and how Sound On Sound works now. The Wow and Flutter sound a bit more 3 dimensional and less “pasted on” but I was hoping they would be more randomized, after listening on better speakers, they are not.
One big improvement is moving the low end contour control to the front panel. It used to be a hidden feature and I don’t think most people knew it’s purpose.
On analog delays the high end is purposefully rolled off to conceal “clock noise “ from the BBD signal. Many people like this sound. It’s “warmer.” Most simulators of analog and tape devices simply roll of the high end, but miss out on an important fact. The Echoplex and Memory Man also roll off the low end!
The Memory Man sounded more like an Echoplex than other analog delays back in the day because of this. It has “presence” it is brighter and less murky compared to other analog delays. People like dark and muddy echoes, and it’s a cool sound, but it is not the sound of real tape, unless your machine is badly in need of a new tape or head cleaning.
Although the El Capistan has this control, it was hidden, and I don’t think most people used it or didn’t use it correctly. Now that it’s on the front panel it’s easier to access and they show it off several times in the videos. Most people really seemed to like the ambient wash of the El Capistan, lots of fans of that sound (the echoes become smeared and blur into an ambient bed of sound very quickly), but it lacks presence and doesn’t sound like tape...unless you adjust that control.
There are several examples in the video where they do and it sounds much more like a real Echoplex or Space Echo. The drum setting sounds like an Echorec minus the random wobble, but Strymon always went over the top with that anyway. Lots of players seem to like the sound of a half broken machine! You can still get those sounds, but now you can also have a delay that sits in the mix and doesn’t dissolve immediately into a blurry mess!
*Edit to add that the Eventide Timefactor is one of many that has a filter that only adjusts the high end, and it looses presence quickly because the low end doesn’t change.